Apartment building with lit windows at dusk
All postsReal Estate Accounting

NOI, Net Income, and Cash Flow: The Rental Property Metrics That Matter and How They Fit Together

The same 12-unit building had $120,384 of NOI, $36,635 of net income, $18,561 of cash flow and a tax loss. Here is what each number means and how they fit together.

REI Financial GroupNovember 10, 202610 min read
  • NOI
  • Cash Flow
  • DSCR
  • Cap Rate
  • Rental Property

Ask how much a rental property made last year and you can get four different answers, all correct.

The 12-unit building in this post had net operating income of $120,384. Its net income was $36,635. Its cash flow was $18,561. And on its tax return it likely showed a loss of about $17,000.

None of those numbers is wrong. Each answers a different question. NOI tells you how the property performs and what it is worth. Net income tells you what it earned after financing. Cash flow tells you what you can actually take out. Taxable income tells you what you owe the IRS. Mixing them up leads to bad decisions: overpaying for a building, underpricing a sale, a refinance that doesn't qualify, or a property that looks profitable while it drains cash.

Below, we build each metric from the ground up, using one example property throughout.

The example property

AssumptionValue
Units12
Market rent$1,500 per unit per month
Purchase price$1,850,000 (land 20%, building 80%)
Loan$1,295,000 (70% of price), 6.5% interest, 30-year amortization
Cash invested$595,000 (down payment plus about $40,000 of closing costs)
Capital reserve$300 per unit per year

All figures are annual and illustrative.

Step 1: From potential rent to effective gross income

Start with what the building could earn, then subtract what it doesn't collect.

LineAmount
Gross potential rent (12 units x $1,500 x 12)$216,000
Less vacancy and credit loss (5%)($10,800)
Plus other income (laundry, pet fees, late fees)$3,600
Effective gross income (EGI)$208,800

Gross potential rent (GPR) is every unit rented at market rent for the full year. No building collects it, which is why it is a starting point and not a result.

Vacancy and credit loss covers empty units, concessions and rent that is billed but never collected. Track the two separately if you can. High vacancy is a leasing or pricing problem. High credit loss is a screening or collections problem.

Effective gross income is the revenue the property actually produces. It is the top line of every metric that follows.

Step 2: Operating expenses, and what doesn't belong there

Operating expenseAmount
Property taxes$24,000
Management fee (8% of collected rent)$16,416
Repairs and maintenance$15,600
Insurance$12,000
Utilities (common areas, water and sewer)$9,600
Turnover and make-ready$6,000
Landscaping, admin and other$4,800
Total operating expenses$88,416

Operating expenses are the costs of running the building day to day. Just as important is what is left out:

  • Mortgage payments. Financing is a choice the owner makes, not a cost of operating the property. Interest comes in later.
  • Capital improvements. A new roof or boiler lasts for years and is treated as an investment, not a monthly cost.
  • Depreciation. A tax and accounting entry, not a cash cost of operations.
  • The owner's own costs. Income taxes, personal travel and the owner's other businesses don't belong on the property's books.

A useful check is the operating expense ratio: operating expenses divided by EGI. Here it is $88,416 / $208,800 = 42.3%. Compare it across your own properties and over time. A ratio that creeps up year after year shows costs growing faster than rent.

One caution: expense ratios only compare fairly when properties are set up alike. A building where tenants pay their own utilities will look far more efficient than one where the owner pays them.

Step 3: Net operating income (NOI)

NOI = effective gross income - operating expenses

$208,800 - $88,416 = $120,384

NOI is the most important number in real estate because it measures the property by itself. It doesn't change based on who owns the building, how much they borrowed or what their tax situation is. That makes it the basis for comparing properties and for valuing them.

NOI and value. Income property is commonly valued by dividing NOI by a capitalization rate, or cap rate:

Value = NOI / cap rate

At the $1,850,000 purchase price, this building's cap rate is $120,384 / $1,850,000 = 6.5%. Turned around, at a 6.5% cap rate every $1 of NOI is worth about $15.38 of property value.

That is why small operating improvements matter. Cutting $1,200 a year from the water bill, or raising other income by $100 a month, adds about $18,500 to the building's value at a 6.5% cap rate. The reverse is also true. A $3,000 roof repair wrongly coded as an operating expense makes NOI look $3,000 lower and the building look about $46,000 less valuable on paper.

Step 4: Debt service and DSCR

The loan payment on $1,295,000 at 6.5% over 30 years is $8,185 a month, or $98,223 a year. In year one, $83,749 of that is interest and $14,475 is principal. The interest share falls and the principal share rises every year.

Lenders look at how comfortably NOI covers the loan payment with the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR):

DSCR = NOI / annual debt service

$120,384 / $98,223 = 1.23x. The property earns $1.23 for every $1 of loan payments.

Minimums vary by lender and loan program. As one example, a June 2026 lender term sheet for Fannie Mae's small multifamily loans lists a minimum DSCR of 1.25x. At 1.23x, this building would fall just short and would need a smaller loan to qualify. Knowing your DSCR before you call a lender saves time and avoids surprises.

Step 5: Net income

Net income (before depreciation) = NOI - interest expense

$120,384 - $83,749 = $36,635

Notice that only the interest is subtracted, not the full $98,223 payment. The $14,475 of principal is not an expense. It reduces the loan balance, so the owner still has that money in the form of equity.

In full accrual accounting, depreciation is also subtracted to get net income. Many owner reports leave it out and let the CPA add it at tax time. Either is fine, as long as everyone knows which version they are looking at.

Step 6: Cash flow

Cash flow is what the owner can actually take out of the property.

LineAmount
Net operating income$120,384
Less total debt service (interest and principal)($98,223)
Less capital reserve (12 units x $300)($3,600)
Cash flow before tax$18,561

Cash flow is lower than net income because it subtracts principal and money set aside for capital work. Those uses of cash are real, even though neither is an expense.

The capital reserve line deserves attention. Roofs, boilers, parking lots and appliances all wear out. A property that shows strong cash flow because it sets nothing aside is borrowing from its future. Some underwriters treat reserves as an operating expense above NOI. Others put them below NOI, as we do here. Pick one convention and use it every time.

A bad year makes the point. If this building replaced $25,000 of roof in one year, cash flow for that year would be negative, while NOI would not change at all. That is not a sign the property is failing. It is why NOI and cash flow have to be read together.

Step 7: Taxable income

The tax return adds one more large deduction: depreciation. Land can't be depreciated, but the building can. U.S. residential rental buildings are generally depreciated over 27.5 years.

  • Building basis: 80% of $1,850,000 = $1,480,000
  • Annual depreciation: $1,480,000 / 27.5 = $53,818

Simplified taxable income: $36,635 net income - $53,818 depreciation = -$17,183.

The property put $18,561 of cash in the owner's pocket and reported a tax loss. This is one of the main tax advantages of owning rental real estate. Whether the owner can use that loss depends on their income, how involved they are in the property and other rules, so this is a conversation for their CPA. The point for operators is to stop treating taxable income as a measure of how the property performed. It isn't one.

Step 8: Return on the owner's cash

Cash-on-cash return = annual cash flow before tax / cash invested

$18,561 / $595,000 = 3.1%

That looks low, and as a pure cash yield it is. But it leaves out the $14,475 of loan principal paid down this year. Adding it gives a total return on cash, before any appreciation, of $33,035 / $595,000 = 5.6%. Both numbers are useful. Cash-on-cash tells the owner what they can spend. Total return tells them what they are building.

Step 9: Break-even occupancy

Break-even occupancy = (operating expenses + debt service) / (gross potential rent + other income)

($88,416 + $98,223) / ($216,000 + $3,600) = 85%

This building covers all its operating costs and loan payments as long as it collects about 85% of its potential income. Below that, the owner is putting money in. It is a simple stress test, and it shows how much room the property has if a few units sit empty or a recession hits.

The metrics side by side

MetricFormulaExampleThe question it answers
Effective gross incomeGPR - vacancy and credit loss + other income$208,800What did the property actually bring in?
Operating expense ratioOperating expenses / EGI42.3%How efficiently is it run?
NOIEGI - operating expenses$120,384How does the property perform, regardless of financing?
Cap rateNOI / value6.5%What is it worth, and how does it compare?
DSCRNOI / debt service1.23xCan it support its loan?
Net incomeNOI - interest$36,635What did it earn after financing?
Cash flow before taxNOI - debt service - capital reserve$18,561What can the owner take out?
Taxable incomeNet income - depreciation-$17,183What goes on the tax return?
Cash-on-cash returnCash flow / cash invested3.1%What is the cash yield on the owner's money?
Break-even occupancy(Operating expenses + debt service) / (GPR + other income)85%How much vacancy can it absorb?

Common mistakes that distort these numbers

  1. Capital work coded as repairs. It understates NOI and value, and makes the expense ratio look worse than it is.
  2. The whole mortgage payment coded as an expense. It understates net income by the amount of principal.
  3. Using pro forma numbers as if they were actual. Asking rents and "stabilized" vacancy are estimates. Underwrite from trailing-twelve-month actuals where you have them.
  4. Ignoring vacancy and credit loss. A building that is 100% leased on paper but collects 94% of its rent has a 6% credit loss problem.
  5. No capital reserve. Cash flow looks strong until the roof fails.
  6. Comparing properties set up differently. Adjust for who pays utilities, whether management is in-house and how reserves are treated before you compare.

What to do this week

  1. Pick one property and calculate EGI, NOI and the operating expense ratio from the last twelve months of actuals.
  2. Check how loan payments and capital work are coded. Principal should hit the loan balance, and long-lived improvements should be capitalized, not expensed.
  3. Calculate DSCR and break-even occupancy, especially for any property with a loan maturing or a refinance coming up.
  4. Decide on a capital reserve per unit and whether it sits above or below NOI, then apply it the same way to every property.
  5. For owners, report NOI and cash flow side by side, so a big capital year isn't mistaken for a bad operating year.

If you'd like help building these metrics into your monthly reporting, REI Financial Group can help.

Sources

Find out what your file is hiding.

A diagnostic review of your AppFolio books. Clear findings, a clear plan.

Book a free AppFolio Diagnostic Review